Blog

The High Cost of Cheap Content


For years, whenever I was short of time, I outsourced the writing of articles for my own websites. The results were sometimes questionable. The pages answered the keyword, but they were stiff and forgettable. I would not have bookmarked them myself. An article bought at the lowest price seems to save money until you count what it fails to do.

EXAMPLE NEEDED FROM MARK: one specific outsourced article or site where the cheap content let you down. Say what was wrong with it, what it was meant to achieve, and what you did about it.

How a bargain article gets made

It usually begins with a brief that is only a keyword, something like "write 800 words about project management software". The writer, or the tool, rewrites whatever already ranks, with surface-level research and no point of view. The voice is generic and tends to exaggerate. The pictures are stock photos or absent. It is produced to fill a calendar, and it dates quickly.

Writing that does better has a purpose beyond ranking. It educates the reader and starts with something particular about the business, and a person shapes the final piece. Google's helpful content update was built to surface pages written for people by someone who knows the subject. Thin AI-generated pages with no human oversight are the kind it targets. That is where Google's rewards for authority content come from. It is also why I treat E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness and Trustworthiness) as the standard to write to.

Bargain articleAuthoritative article
BriefA keyword and a word countA sentence only your business could say
ResearchA rewrite of what already ranksSources checked and linked
VoiceGeneric, tends to exaggerateEdited by hand, in an expert's voice
ImagesStock photos or noneTwo or three made for the article
Shelf lifeDates quicklyUpdated and kept

Where authoritative writing sits

A site needs three kinds of writing. Social updates and news announcements are brief and short-lived. Sales pages are focused on getting a visitor to act now. In between sit the authoritative pages, the in-depth material such as guides and detailed explanations of how you work. They are what convinces a hesitant customer who is still researching. A small business cannot outspend a large competitor on advertising. It can explain its subject better, on its own website. If you decide to hire help, look for an authoritative content writer who asks why before asking what.

A process that earns trust

The brief comes first. I ask for a foundation sentence that says something only your business can say. One example would be why your software was built for remote creative agencies, because you found that existing tools made the feedback loop on visual files too complicated. That sentence guides the whole piece.

I then use AI as a research assistant, to gather information and produce a rough first draft. On complicated topics that saves a good deal of time. The AI writes the rough draft and I am the author. Every robotic sentence is rewritten by hand, headings are rebuilt so a reader can follow the argument, and the finished piece is checked for plagiarism. I explain the full method in how I blend AI and human editing.

Trust depends on more than the text. I create two or three custom images for each article, and they can carry your brand elements. I embed relevant video where you have it. I link to your other pages and to respected outside sources, and I write the title and meta description for search results. For clients on WordPress or a similar system, the article can arrive formatted and ready to publish.

What you get back

The shift fits where search is going, since Google keeps pushing towards pages made for people by people who know the subject. A visitor who has read a detailed guide and then clicks through to your service page arrives informed. That is a warmer lead than one who came off a sales page alone. A specialist freelancer also costs a small business less than a full-time senior writer.

Making the change

Start with your best-performing pages and ask if they explain why you work the way you do, or only describe what you sell. Pick the one distinctive thing your business knows and build the next article around it. Publish fewer, better pieces. One guide a month that people remember is worth more than four they forget. Judge a writer by the questions they ask about your reasons and your process. Word count and turnaround time tell you very little.

Ready to build something that lasts?

Tell me what makes your business genuinely different.

Get in touch